Historic Homes for Sale in Lancaster County, PA

Historic Charm Meets Modern Luxury in Desirable West End Lancaster in this former Keener Manufacturing Company building! Step into timeless elegance with this stunning all-brick historic home located in Lancaster’s sought-after West End neighborhood. Spanning three levels, this meticulously maintained residence offers the perfect blend of original character and modern convenience. The main level welcomes you with a spacious living room featuring gleaming hardwood floors and recessed lighting. The formal dining room showcases an exposed brick accent wall and rustic wood ceiling beam—ideal for entertaining. The modern kitchen impresses with stainless steel appliances, ample counter space, skylight, vaulted ceiling and exposed wood beam details. A convenient powder room and laundry area complete this level. A beautiful custom-made staircase leads you to the upper floors. The second level features a spacious primary bedroom with a walk-in closet, private bath, and access to a charming balcony. An additional room on this floor, currently used as a family room, offers flexibility for a home office, guest space, or den. The third level includes two generously sized bedrooms and a full bath—perfect for guests, children, or a play room. The lower level provides even more living space, featuring a bonus room currently used as a home gym and a recreation room complete with a pool table—ideal for entertaining or relaxing. Outside, enjoy warm evenings on the deck or unwind on the patio—perfect spaces for grilling, dining, or simply enjoying the beautifully landscaped setting. This one-of-a-kind home blends historic character with modern amenities in one of Lancaster’s most desirable neighborhoods. Don’t miss your opportunity to own a piece of West End charm. Schedule your showing today!

$549,000 ACTIVE

409 Lancaster Avenue Lancaster, Pennsylvania

4 Beds 3 Baths 3,602 SqFt 0.03 Acres

$739,000 ACTIVE

11 E Walnut Street Lancaster, Pennsylvania

5 Beds 4 Baths 2,520 SqFt 0.05 Acres

Welcome to 1080 Georgetown Rd in Quarryville—a rare opportunity to own a spacious 5-bedroom, 3-bath two-unit home with over a century of history and exceptional craftsmanship. Originally built in 1878 as a duplex and later converted into a single-family residence by the Sterling/Elmer family, the home features custom woodwork by master carpenter John “Jack” Elmer, including built-ins, crown molding, and a Williamsburg-style fireplace. A separate second-floor unit with private entrance, kitchen, laundry, and balcony offers flexibility for rental income or guest use. The 1996 addition provides a private living space ideal for multigenerational living, complete with its own entrance, bedroom, bath, and living area. Additional highlights include a sunroom with backyard views, upgraded electrical, a fenced yard with gardens, a circular driveway, and a detached 3-car garage—all in a peaceful rural setting.

$614,900 ACTIVE

1080 Georgetown Paradise, Pennsylvania

5 Beds 3 Baths 3,116 SqFt 0.3 Acres

This spacious 4-bedroom home offers over 2,700 sqft of beautifully balanced living and entertaining space—perfect for a growing family or hosting friends year-round. The remodeled kitchen features granite countertops, built-in pantry and trash compactor and opens to a formal dining room, ideal for holiday gatherings or dinner parties. The large family room, which opens to the deck, allows the flow of everyone to mingle inside and out. The living room and large covered porch allows for those wanting out of the crowd to sit and relax. The oversized owner’s suite, with a balcony overlooking the pool, offers comfort and flexibility with room to customize for your future needs.
Step outside to your personal retreat—complete with an in-ground pool, built-in bar, entertainment deck,
Gas tiki torches, Gas fire pit and a perfectly landscaped horseshoe pit with lighting. The huge wraparound porch adds charm and space for relaxing evenings. There are 2 garages for a combined total of 3 cars and both include a bonus loft space above—perfect for kids’ playroom, home office, or creative studio. Both loft area are accessed from the pool deck. The property also includes a pet electric fence.
Located just blocks from the town center and train station, this home blends everyday convenience with room to thrive. Central air, natural gas hot water custom covered baseboard heat, and unique outdoor features make this one a must-see. This IS THAT HOUSE you have admired from the street for years!!! Now it could be yours!!

$574,900 ACTIVE

662 S Market Street Elizabethtown, Pennsylvania

4 Beds 2 Baths 2,779 SqFt 0.33 Acres

FOR SALE! Hard to find warehouse in the prestigious Musser Park neighborhood ripe for development! This +/- 5,000 SF building features 16' ceilings, 1.5 baths, indoor parking, and a floor plan fit for Lancaster's next single family warehouse conversion. This convenient location features quick access to Lancaster's Central Business District as well as local highways. Utilize the current approved plan for 6 apartment units (plan available in MLS documents) with indoor parking or bring your own idea to this unique property. This building will not last long - schedule your showing today!

$569,000 ACTIVE

218 E Madison Street Lancaster, Pennsylvania

3 Beds 2 Baths 5,004 SqFt 0.11 Acres

This historic Federal-style home, built in 1814, offers a unique opportunity to own a spacious and character-filled residence on the main square in Marietta, PA. With 18 fireplaces, soaring ceilings, and generous rooms, the home exudes timeless charm and elegance. The property features multiple suites and stately common areas, making it ideal for those seeking a grand single-family residence. Conveniently located near local restaurants, taverns, and the rail trail, it also provides easy access to outdoor activities along the river and the many attractions of Lancaster County. The home is fully furnished and includes a natural gas heating system installed in 2018. This is your a chance to bring new life to this remarkable piece of history.

$525,000 ACTIVE

219 W Market Street Marietta, Pennsylvania

7 Beds 8 Baths 7,952 SqFt 0.25 Acres

THIS PROPERTY IS GOING TO AUCTION ON WEDNESDAY JUNE 4, 2025 @ 6:00 PM. THE LIST PRICE ONLY REFLECTS THE SUGGESTED STARTING BID. Completely renovated "Log Cabin" style house while keeping all its history charm including a 3-year old addition integrated into the same time period. It feels like a museum but includes all the current comforts to make it more day-to-day friendly. The original part of the house was built between 1790-1800 with a later kitchen addition and third spacious addition in 2022, it's like stepping back in time. Kitchen/dining cabinetry incorporated old cupboards and wooden boxes to fit the time period, includes all stainless steel appliances. 2022 great room addition is post/beam construction, fireplace mantle, 15' cathedral ceilings, powder bathroom, adjoining room with remarkable walk-in original stone fireplace, living room with log walls, laundry room with sink. Inviting front and rear covered porches, 20' x 6' rear concrete patio. Second level has 3 bedrooms, landing area, primary 11.5' x 9' walk-in closet, full bathroom with shower. Two new heat pumps and A/C in 2022, central vac. Detached garage is a concrete block 28' x 40' garage/shop, plenty of room for vehicles. 1-12' x 9' overhead door and 1-9' x 7' overhead door, concrete floor, electric service. This is a rare opportunity to live in a "Log Cabin" style house restored in all its glory with modern amenities for luxury living. Property has a large pond beside the road so the buildings can set back away from traffic. Truly a must-see property if you enjoy the "Late Revolutionary" part of American history.

$490,000 ACTIVE

1606 Reading Road Mohnton, Pennsylvania

3 Beds 2 Baths 2,640 SqFt 1.7 Acres

This incredible, newly renovated home offers the ultimate in Lancaster City living. The location near downtown provides easy access to all that the city has to offer, from fine dining to the arts scene, to endless shopping options. Just a short walk away are several of the major city hubs, F&M University, Lancaster General hospital, and Clipper Magazine Stadium. As for the home itself, you'll be delighted from the moment you arrive. The surrounding neighborhood is a pleasant, eclectic mix of beautiful residential homes and the shops and restaurants that make Lancaster such an amazing place to call home; The Belvedere, 401 Prime, and Decades are all a short walk away. The inviting front porch provides a lovely place to watch the world go by, and walking inside you'll find a spacious, beautiful living area showcasing a generous foyer and an abundance of built- in shelving, plus a half bath for your convenience. The warm, newly refinished hardwood floors, along with ornate trim work help the home retain much of its old world charm. You'll be delighted by the kitchen, which features all the high end finishes you'd expect in a home of this caliber. Beyond the kitchen is a space that will serve beautifully as a second living area or a dining room, which through large glass doors opens to an outdoor seating area and the spacious backyard beyond. Moving upstairs, the primary suite is a stunner, with custom trim and a walk-in closet, and a beautiful tile bathroom featuring a dual vanity and large soaking tub, and its own balcony overlooking the backyard. Also on the second floor is a conveniently located laundry room, a beautifully finished guest bath, and two more bedrooms. On the third floor you'll find one more bedroom to bring the bedroom count to four. And more on the backyard, there's plenty of space for pets or children to enjoy, all encircled by a wooden privacy fence and partially shaded. For your peace of mind, renovations include all new mechanicals including electrical, plumbing, HVAC, and more. The large basement provides lots of storage if needed, as well as ample closets throughout the home. Don't miss this exceptional opportunity to own a prime portion of thriving Lancaster City!

$479,000 ACTIVE

614 N Queen Street Lancaster, Pennsylvania

4 Beds 3 Baths 1,921 SqFt 0.06 Acres

Welcome to 152 W Main Street—where charm meets modern convenience in this fully updated 3-bedroom, 1.5-bath detached home. Everything has been redone, so you can move right in and start enjoying the good life. The home has been redone completely, making it an ideal turnkey residence, short-term rental, or weekend retreat.

Step outside and soak in the private hot tub, or take advantage of the spacious barn out back—perfect for storage, hobbies, or your next creative project. Just minutes from Lancaster, it makes this a great place to commute to the city.

$475,000 ACTIVE

152 W Main Street Leola, Pennsylvania

3 Beds 3 Baths 1,544 SqFt 0.5 Acres

Don’t miss this incredible investment opportunity at 445 N Duke Street, Lancaster! This duplex offers multiple income-generating possibilities—perfect for a savvy investor looking to take on the property Subject To or an owner-occupant seeking a "live and rent" setup. With two units ready for value-add potential, you can maximize cash flow while enjoying the benefits of a sought-after location. The seller is open to creative financing options, making this an even more attractive deal. Located near downtown Lancaster, shopping, dining, and commuter routes, this is a rare chance to secure a high-potential property. Schedule your showing today!
Oh and Guess what!! It has a 2-car garage right across the street from a Trauma 1 hospital! Would be wonderful for Mid term rentals or House Hacking, where you can live in one and rent out the other unit to offset your cost of living!!

$475,000 ACTIVE

445 N Duke Street Lancaster, Pennsylvania

6 Beds 4 Baths 2,904 SqFt 0.05 Acres

$450,000 ACTIVE

334 Church Street Lancaster, Pennsylvania

1 Beds 1 Baths 930 SqFt 0.09 Acres

AUCTION. This property is being sold at auction. The current list price is the recommended starting bid, however the seller is also accepting pre-auction offers. This property may be sold as a standard listing prior to the auction. If the seller accepts an offer prior to the auction, the auction will be canceled.

If you are looking for the perfect house for a large family and to entertain for hours - this house is a fantastic opportunity, you don't want to miss it! Featuring 7 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms, you will have plenty of space. This unique home has 2 dining rooms, 2 living rooms,1 bar, 8 amazing fireplaces and indoor jacuzzi tub!

This open concept home creates a seamless flow, with so much potential. After you are amazed by the inside, take a step outside to see the beautiful 1.9 acres. There is a large barn and storage studio waiting to be used for anything you can imagine. Come out to see this enchanting home in Manheim Central.

The property is being sold in "AS IS" condition. The auction will take place at the property and with online bidding at 11am on Saturday, May 10.

Online bidding is available from now through the live auction. The auctioneer will be live onsite accepting bids from in-person bidders and online bidders. The seller is considering pre-auction offers. If the seller accepts a pre-auction offer, the auction will be canceled. Please note that all written offers will be presented to the seller.

The MLS listing price is the suggested opening bid for the auction and may not reflect the reserve price. We expect the property to sell for a higher amount than the MLS list price. Offers that more closely match the terms of the auction, such as those with no financing or inspection contingencies, have a higher likelihood of being accepted by the seller. An inspection report is available for this property. Please review the auction documents attached to this listing. The buyer is responsible for all transfer taxes when a property is sold at auction. The auction terms include a 10% buyer's premium added to the high bid.

There is no obligation to add the buyer's premium to a pre-auction offer. The price of a pre-auction offer, if accepted, will be the total purchase price. There will be no additional buyer's premium added to pre-auction offers. Naturally, the seller will consider the total financial value of accepting an offer prior to the auction.

$425,000 ACTIVE

742 Power Road Manheim, Pennsylvania

7 Beds 3 Baths 5,094 SqFt 1.8 Acres

Historic end-unit rowhome, originally built in 1900. This spacious four-bedroom residence offers urban living at its finest. Inside, you'll find high ceilings, hardwood floors, beautiful stained glass windows, and a decorative fireplace. The kitchen has stainless steel appliances and opens into a main floor laundry. Situated in a walkable, vibrant neighborhood, this home is walking distance to local cafes, shops, and parks.

$425,000 ACTIVE

227 Elm Street Lancaster, Pennsylvania

4 Beds 2 Baths 2,266 SqFt 0.06 Acres

Welcome home to this beautifully renovated colonial home, in the desirable and rural Southern Lancaster County. This home boasts high ceilings, new flooring, new kitchen, updated bathrooms, and so much more. You will have plenty of room for entertaining on this almost half an acre lot, and over 3000 square feet of finished living space. You'll also enjoy with plenty of space for parking with the huge driveway and detached garage, as well as storage in the full daylight basement. This won't last long, call to set up your showing today!

$420,000 ACTIVE

1142 River Road Holtwood, Pennsylvania

5 Beds 3 Baths 3,000 SqFt 0.4 Acres

Welcome to your dream home in the heart of Chestnut Hill! Nestled on a quiet one-way street across from the picturesque Lancaster Theological Seminary, this beautifully maintained 4-bedroom, 2-bathroom townhouse seamlessly blends historic charm with modern comfort. From the moment you arrive, the white painted brick exterior and inviting front porch with a classic porch swing set the tone for the warmth and character found throughout. Step inside to discover rich original hardwood floors that flow through spacious, light-filled living spaces. The main level offers a spacious living room centered around a stunning brick gas fireplace, complete with decorative lava rocks and black glass. Just beyond, the formal dining room is flooded with natural light and leads into a gourmet kitchen featuring corian black quartz countertops, stainless steel appliances, ambient lighting, and an ornate tin ceiling. A full bathroom on this level boasts a sleek stainless steel walk-in shower with a heat lamp and a modern vanity with built-in electrical outlets for convenience. Enjoy direct access from the kitchen to a private two-level deck—ideal for summer gatherings. Upstairs, the second level features three bedrooms, each with its own closet with built-in shelving. The rear bedroom opens to a balcony overlooking the fenced backyard, creating the perfect spot to unwind. The spacious primary bedroom includes a large walk-in closet and offers picturesque views of the gothic architecture of Lancaster Theological Seminary. A centrally located full bathroom with a tub-shower combo serves this level. On the third floor, you’ll find a spacious fourth bedroom beautiful natural light and a walk-in closet adorned with vintage wallpaper—an ideal guest room, office, or creative space. The unfinished basement offers laundry facilities and endless potential, with walk-out access via Belco doors to the backyard. A gated locked alleyway provides convenient front-to-back access. Located within walking distance of Franklin & Marshall College, the city’s best restaurants and bars, and the local dog park, this home offers the best of Lancaster living. Don’t miss your chance to own this one-of-a-kind property—schedule your private showing today!

$399,500 ACTIVE

545 N Pine Street Lancaster, Pennsylvania

4 Beds 2 Baths 1,644 SqFt 0.04 Acres

Ask us how you can get this home at a 5.5% mortgage interest rate for the first year of ownership!

Step into Lancaster’s rich history with this timeless beauty! Full of character, space, and fresh updates and located in one of the city’s most walkable neighborhoods. This 4-bedroom, 2-bath home blends historic charm with modern comfort, offering over 2,000 square feet of refined living.

From the inviting covered front porch with ornate wood trim to the arched window frames and solid brick exterior, this home makes a lasting first impression. Inside, you’ll find soaring ceilings, refinished hardwood floors, tall picture windows, and architectural details like arched doorways, window seats, and built-in cabinetry that reflect its storied past.

Fresh paint throughout creates a bright, clean look, complemented by recent upgrades including a new A/C system, energy-efficient heat pump, and updated HVAC. The fenced backyard with paver patio is ideal for relaxing or entertaining, and the walk-out balcony provides the perfect spot to enjoy city views with your morning coffee.

Located in the heart of Lancaster City, you’re just minutes from local shops, restaurants, markets, and cultural attractions. Bonus: one off-street parking space is prepaid through the end of the year!

Whether you’re drawn to the charm, the location, or the potential to personalize, this is a home worth seeing. Schedule your tour today and ask us how to take advantage of the interest rate reducer incentive!

$389,899 ACTIVE

335 W Walnut Street Lancaster, Pennsylvania

4 Beds 2 Baths 2,149 SqFt 0.04 Acres

Charming Historic Home in Churchtown, Lancaster County! Step into timeless elegance with this beautiful home featuring 4 bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms. Home features 9' ceilings, custom built-ins, and rich hardwood floors that showcase the home's craftsmanship and character. Custom woodworking throughout adds warmth and charm, while modern upgrades - including an updated electric panel - offer peace of mind. Enjoy the cozy ambiance of the partially finished lower level with exposed stone walls - perfect for a home office, den, or entertaining space. Breathtaking farmland views surround the property, providing a serene rural atmosphere. A 2-story barn with a 2-car garage adds both functionality and rustic appeal. All this, just under 5 miles from the PA Turnpike, making commuting a breeze while you enjoy the tranquility of country living. Don't miss this rare opportunity to own a piece of Churchtown history!

$385,000 ACTIVE

2140 Main Street Narvon, Pennsylvania

4 Beds 2 Baths 2,574 SqFt 0.26 Acres

AUCTION: Accepting Pre-Auction Offers! Located in the desirable Lampeter-Strasburg School District, this 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath home offers a great combination of space and location. One bedroom is currently used as a home office, and the primary bedroom includes an en suite bath and a private balcony.

The custom kitchen was fully updated in 2020 with quartz countertops while the connecting formal and casual dining areas make hosting a breeze. The generous family room provides plenty of space to relax and entertain. A spacious deck overlooks the large backyard, which borders the West Lampeter Fairgrounds.

Additional highlights include a 3-car garage, easy walkability to the LS school campus, and a short walk to local favorites like Lampeter Cafe with Joe on the Go, Pebbles & Lace Boutique, and Waltz Vineyards. The home is also near the YMCA and its walking trails, and offers convenient access to Lancaster, Route 30, shopping outlets, and more.

This property is scheduled to be sold at Auction on Saturday, June 28. The Seller is also accepting pre-auction offers. If an offer is accepted prior to the auction, the auction will be canceled.

$375,000 ACTIVE

1626 Lampeter Road Lancaster, Pennsylvania

4 Beds 3 Baths 2,710 SqFt 0.72 Acres

This charming detached home at 226 E Frederick St offers the best of city living. Nestled in a prime location just a block from LGH/Penn Medicine and a short stroll from Central Market, Lancaster Amtrak Station, and other city attractions, convenience is at your doorstep.
The spacious 4-bedroom layout provides ample room for comfortable living, enhanced by an extra-wide lot and off-street parking—a rare find in the heart of Lancaster. Thoughtful upgrades bring modern appeal to this well-maintained home, including a durable metal roof, stylishly fenced yard with Tree House and granite steps leading to the front entrance, updated sidewalk, parking pad, and patio.
Inside, the attention to detail continues with wood flooring that adds warmth and sophistication. Sunlight filters through replacement windows, creating a bright and welcoming atmosphere. The remodeled kitchen is a dream for home chefs, boasting stainless steel appliances and elegant granite countertops, and ample space for adding a butcher block cart or island.
Climate control is effortless with four mini-splits, ensuring year-round comfort. Every update has been chosen with care, combining practicality with aesthetic appeal.
If you're looking for a home that blends historic character with modern convenience, this home is the one.

$375,000 ACTIVE

226 E Frederick Street Lancaster, Pennsylvania

4 Beds 1 Baths 1,721 SqFt 0.05 Acres

Tucked into the heart of the desirable Chestnut Hill neighborhood, and around the corner from the Chestnut Hill cafe, this 3-bedroom, 2-bath home delivers warmth, character, and the kind of charm you don’t see in newer builds. From the moment you step inside, you’re greeted by solid wood floors, natural light, and a cozy exposed brick wall in the dining room that instantly makes the space feel like home.
The fenced-in backyard is perfect for four-legged friends, summer BBQs, or quiet morning coffee. Plus, off-street parking means no circling the block after a long day.
Need more space? The unfinished attic offers incredible potential—ideal for a future bonus room, home office, or guest retreat.
Whether you’re a first-time buyer, growing family, or someone who’s ready for a home that’s as full of character as it is possibility—this is the one.
You’ll love:
-The warmth of real hardwoods throughout the first floor
-2 full baths—no more sharing!
-Chestnut Hill’s charm + convenience
-The opportunity to make the attic your own
This one won’t last—contact your agent today for a showing!

$359,000 ACTIVE

125 Nevin Street Lancaster, Pennsylvania

3 Beds 2 Baths 1,785 SqFt 0.06 Acres